Tesla's Full Self-Driving mode is nowhere near autonomous, but it claimed it was back in 2016. This seems dangerous, but Tesla fans beg to differ.
www.autonocion.com
I think that is a fair criticism of Musk
According to ChatGPT:
Tesla FSD (Full Self-Driving) is sometimes safer than humans in limited conditions, but overall it is NOT proven safer than humans in all real-world driving.
"By Tesla’s own math, it reveals that its robotaxis are 4x worse at driving than humans, with redactions hiding even more details":
By NHTSA standards, the Tesla Robotaxis are 8x worse than human drivers.
fortune.com
Competitor data:
Waymo (Level 4 — actually driverless)
What the data shows:
~90% fewer serious crashes than humans
~10× fewer injury crashes in some reporting
Statistically lower injury + airbag crashes across multiple categories
Millions of miles with no driver at all
Key point:
This is the only system here that can replace a human driver (in limited areas)
Reality:
Works only in mapped cities + controlled conditions
Doesn’t try to drive everywhere
Verdict:
YES - Waymo is genuinely safer than human drivers (where it operates)
The gap is NOT small - it’s huge:
Waymo = true autonomous system (robot driver)
Tesla = driver assistance
That’s why:
Waymo can legally run driverless taxis
Tesla cannot
My take:
1. Full self-driving is a desperately-needed technology:
* The United States has the highest total number of car accidents in the world
* We kill 40,000 Americans on U.S. roads every year
* 34 people die every day in America from drunk-driving crashes
* There are over 2 million car accident injuries annual in the states
* ~1.2 million die worldwide every year from car accidents (2 deaths every
minute)
* We need better solutions for young & old drivers, as well as people with other impairments (injuries, disabilities, substance abuse, etc.)
2. People take issue not so much with the technology, but with unbridled capitalism:
* It's the same with A.I.: the issue is not really about the technology
itself, it's the way it's
managed &
advertised
* Tesla unleashed a self-driving beta on public roads, which has
literally killed people, whereas Waymo has done it in a much more responsible manner on controlled roads
* They also hyped it up to seems like it does more than it does & that it would be fully available "any day now"
3. Tesla has been VERY careful about the actual legalities of their FSD software:
* Illegal lying (fraud) has not clearly proven for Tesla FSD in a court case (to date, at least).
* The root issue is really "overly optimistic CEO predictions", which are treated in the business world as “forward-looking statements”
* I don't agree with this or like this at all. After my Jeep Renegade fiasco, I learned to only buy what is available & reliable right now,
today. The article you posted points that out with all of the different hardware revisions available that never truly line up to what is being hyped-up...
tbh today's Tesla FSD is absolutely
incredible & they could market it just on actual existing features alone. Plus, people like to be a part of something exciting & get new features, so Tesla could have spoon-fed updates for
decades that way, rather than just saying "Autopilot
real soon now".
Same issue with their Optimus robot: they advertised fully-autonomous robots that were actually being tele-operated, which soured things a bit. Instead, they could have simply marketed it as a bipedal
remote-control robot to help grandma in her own home or be able to WFH with disabilities or any NUMBER of
amazing use-case scenarios!!
The primary reason I don't own a Tesla right now is because I don't have easy charging access. I was hoping the Cybertruck would have the 500-mile battery, but now it's just a political boat anchor. But as far as FSD, as with AI, "today will be the worst it will ever be", and self-driving cars are DEFINITELY overdue for humanity's safety!!
Also, I can't see the future, but I don't think Tesla can effectively achieve FSD without LIDAR. As the technology stands today, it's really quite phenomenal, but I don't think the current hardware stack can drive me to the airport, then drive itself home & park lol. Especially not with this annoucement:
Americans have likely been as fascinated with cars as long as apple pie and baseball have defined the U.S. culture.
www.mheducation.com